National Productivity Week 27th November 2023 | Visit Website

A diverse community of
leading experts, policymakers
and practitioners

The Institute’s key research themes
are led by ten academic partners
spread across the UK.

Businesses are crucial to solving
the UK’s productivity problems.

We’re a UK-wide research
organisation exploring what
productivity means for business

Businesses are crucial to solving
the UK’s productivity problems.

Environmentally-adjusted productivity measures for the UK

Standard productivity measures follow a private goods perspective, assuming free disposal of bad outputs. But from a social welfare perspective, productivity measures would internalise production externalities. We explore four deviations from the standard measures, including:

  • examining energy productivity;
  • incorporating greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions as an input;
  • incorporating GHG and non-GHG air pollutants as ‘bad outputs’;
  • and incorporating environmental protection as a ‘good’ output.

Our contribution is two-fold: we believe we are the first to treat environmental protection expenditure as capital investment in the UK context; and, where previous studies have incorporated emissions into economy-wide productivity measures, we utilise the richness of UK data to construct sector-specific environmentally-adjusted productivity for up to 42 industries. UK energy-productivity has more than doubled since 1990, and emissions-productivity almost tripled. Incorporating emissions increases measured output and labour productivity growth, but not enough to explain the productivity puzzle. In some industries, incorporating emissions and pollutants turns GVA negative. Industry-level data indicates that these rapid growths are mostly due to increased efficiency within industries, with only 8-21% due to changing industrial composition since 1990. Incorporating environmental protection as a ‘good’ output raises the level of GVA by around 6-7%, but does not significantly alter its growth rate.

Authors Josh Martin (Bank of England and ESCoE) and Matthew Agarwala (Bennett Institute for Public Policy, University of Cambridge)

Themes

  • Transitions

Published

09/11/2022

Cite

M. Agarwala, J. Martin (2022) Environmentally-adjusted productivity measures for the UK. Working Paper No. 028, The Productivity Institute.